TL;DR Summary Box
Spray dryers used in pharmaceutical and food industries present a significant explosion risk due to the presence of fine combustible dust, oxygen and ignition sources within a confined environment. The highest risk often occurs when materials are fully dried, as lower moisture content reduces the energy required for ignition.
Explosion protection in spray dryers typically relies on two main strategies: explosion venting and explosion suppression, often combined with chemical explosion isolation. Venting systems are cost-effective but can be limited by indoor installation constraints and may be overdesigned based on conservative assumptions. Explosion suppression systems offer a more advanced solution by detecting incipient deflagrations and rapidly releasing suppressant agents to prevent pressure build-up and structural damage.
A critical but often overlooked hazard is smouldering, a slow flameless combustion process that can occur in high-moisture zones and lead to fires or explosions. Because of this, prevention systems such as carbon monoxide (CO) monitoring are essential for early detection. CO detection provides real-time monitoring of abnormal conditions, enabling operators to act before ignition occurs and making it one of the most effective preventive safety measures in spray dryer operations.
One of the most common processing operations in the pharmaceutical and food industries is the heating of a solution (slurry) or wet powder to remove moisture and produce a solid, dry product. The purpose of drying is primarily to facilitate product handling, such as the encapsulation of pharmaceutical tablets, to enhance shelf life through better preservation, and to achieve economic benefits by reducing the weight and volume of the final product for transportation.
Spray dryers are widely used in food, pharmaceutical and chemical processing industries where fine powders and combustible dusts create a significant explosion and fire risk. Understanding explosion protection methods such as venting, suppression and early detection systems is critical for safe and compliant operation.
Subscribe to PII and receive:
Our long-established bi-monthly digital magazine *Process Industry Informer*, featuring exclusive articles, news and updates across the Process Industries, plus commentary from our three industry experts:
Sean Moran
Gavin Smith
Dave Green
PLUS:
- Process Industry Update — our weekly e-newsletter
- PII Podcast
- Special messages from our advertising partners
Why spray dryers present a dust explosion risk
The vast majority of solid organic materials, whether naturally occurring or industrially processed, when present as dust or in bulk form, pose a potential explosion hazard if the conditions defined by the explosion pentagon are satisfied. These five conditions can be summarised as follows:
- The dust particles are typically smaller than 500 μm (micrometers).
- The concentration of the dust cloud is above the Minimum Explosible Concentration (MEC)
- An atmosphere containing oxygen is present.
- An effective ignition source exists.
- All of the above conditions occur simultaneously within a confined vessel.
How drying increases explosion risk in spray drying systems
The paradox that drying process units face is that when the purpose of evaporating the solvent from the solid is accomplished, is when the solid has the highest sensitivity to being ignited, and therefore, cause a deflagration. The next graph shows a curve confronting MIE Minimum Ignition Energy of several organic products in relation with the moisture content within the solid.
Figure 1. Influence of dust moisture content on minimum electric spark ignition energy (MIE) for three dusts. (based on an image from Laar, G.F.M. van, and Zeeuwen, J.P.: On the Minimum Ignition Energy of Dust-Air Mixtures. Archivum Combustionis 5 (1985))
As illustrated by the graph, lower moisture content reduces the energy required to ignite the solid, thereby increasing the likelihood of a deflagration event. Among the various heating and drying units used in industry, the spray dryer is the most prevalent. It is considered the flagship technology in the process industries, particularly when high-throughput continuous operation is required.
The spray dryer is primarily designed for the injection of wet product and hot air at high pressures, atomizing the liquid into fine droplets. These droplets are then dispersed into a large drying chamber, where process temperatures can reach up to 200 °C.
“The vast majority of solid organic materials, whether naturally occurring or industrially processed, when present as dust or in bulk form, pose a potential explosion hazard if the conditions defined by the explosion pentagon are satisfied.”
Typically, the product has a residence time of only a few seconds and is dried before reaching the chamber walls to prevent buildup. A filtration system, such as a cyclone, a dust collector, or a combination of both, recovers the dried product fines and separates them from the air stream. In some cases, a vibro-fluidizer is installed beneath the main drying chamber; its vibrations prevent the newly formed powder from agglomerating as it cools.
In terms of explosion protection techniques available for spray dryers there are basically two: Explosion Venting and Explosion Suppression, both are typically combined with Chemical Explosion Isolation due to the large interconnection piping diameters.
Explosion venting systems for spray dryers
Explosion venting has long been established as the classical mitigation strategy for protecting spray dryers and remains widely used due to its relative simplicity and cost-effectiveness. However, practical implementation can be constrained by the typical indoor installation of spray dryers.
While ductwork can be employed to safely discharge flames and pressure outdoors, building structures often pose challenges, as walls may be too distant or inaccessible for vent ducts. Given the importance of maintaining high temperatures and minimising heat losses, most drying operations are conducted indoors, making the use of ductwork essential whenever explosion venting is applied.
Standard calculations for explosion venting areas, according to NFPA 68 and EN 14491, conservatively assume that the drying chamber is fully occupied by a dust cloud at optimum concentration under relatively high turbulence.
Empirical measurements across a variety of spray dryer configurations, however, indicate that only portions of the drying chamber typically contain a flammable atmosphere, and within these sections, dust concentrations and turbulence levels are often below the assumed optimum.
Consequently, venting areas derived from international standards may often exceed what is technically required for effective protection. The German VDI 2263 provides comprehensive guidance on this matter.
“Explosion venting has long been established as the classical mitigation strategy for protecting spray dryers and remains widely used due to its relative simplicity and cost-effectiveness.”
Explosion suppression systems for spray dryers
Chemical explosion suppression combined with explosion isolation represents the most advanced methodology for explosion mitigation in spray dryers currently available. Over the past decades, this technology has evolved significantly and has gained widespread recognition in the industry due to its high reliability and proven effectiveness.
Suppression systems operate on the principle of ultrafast detection of incipient deflagrations. When a potential explosion is detected within the spray dryer chamber, the signal is immediately transmitted to the explosion protection controller. The controller’s algorithm then instantaneously triggers the HRD (High Rate Discharge) suppressors.
These suppressors are pre-charged with a suppressant agent, commonly sodium bicarbonate, and pressurised with nitrogen at 900 psig (62 barg). Upon activation, the suppressant is rapidly injected into the drying chamber, quenching the explosion at its earliest stage by absorbing the heat of combustion.
As a result, the internal pressure, referred to as Total Suppressed Pressure (TSP), remains below the design pressure of the spray dryer, preventing structural damage and averting catastrophic failure.
Furthermore, chemical suppression systems installed in the interconnecting piping prevent explosion propagation and mitigate the risk of destructive secondary explosions.
Common fire and explosion risks in spray dryers
The typical risks associated with spray dryers have been extensively reported over the last decades. Among the possible causes of accident, we can list; electrostatic discharges, failure to control the process temperature, auto-ignition, hot work and smouldering. The latter has caught the attention of operators for being an unknown phenomenon and a real threat in some specific processes.
Smouldering in spray dryers: a hidden fire risk
All organic and combustible materials exhibit a critical temperature above which spontaneous ignition can occur. Two key parameters are essential for operators of drying systems to understand; the minimum ignition temperature in a cloud (MITc) and the minimum ignition temperature in a layer (MITL).
These parameters are intrinsically linked to the risk of explosions and fires within drying equipment. Consequently, operators must ensure that ignition sources are minimized and process temperatures maintained with adequate safety margins to prevent these hazards.
Smouldering is a slow, incomplete, flameless combustion process that generates carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and water vapour, accompanied by heat release.
This phenomenon is particularly prevalent in powdered milk and infant formula, especially in spray-drying systems, and typically progresses through two well-defined phases:
In the first phase, the product adheres or agglomerates in sections of the dryer that exhibit higher moisture content, such as the area surrounding the injector.
“Smouldering is a slow, incomplete, flameless, combustion process that generates carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide and water vapour, accompanied by heat release.”
In the second phase, the heat supplied by the dryer causes the agglomerated product to overheat, leading to the onset of smouldering, which in turn can give rise to an open flame. This open flame acts as the initiator and primary cause of a fire or explosion, particularly since the dryer chamber contains airborne powder.
Aware of the risks associated with smouldering in spray dryers, and in accordance with VDI 2263 recommendations, carbon monoxide detection systems are employed, such as Hobré CO monitoring system.
This system primarily detects smouldering via CO measurement ports located at various inlet and outlet points throughout the air streams. Readings are centralized in a control unit, which compares the measurements and triggers alarm signals if smouldering is detected. Systems of this type have proven to be the most effective and reliable method for preventing fires and explosions in spray dryers.
Bulletproof Protection for Spray Dryers: Venting, Suppression & Carbon Monoxide Control
Fire and explosion safety in spray dryers requires integrating effective mitigation and prevention measures. Traditional explosion venting is cost-efficient but often limited in indoor applications. Modern chemical suppression systems provide rapid, reliable explosion control. However, prevention remains the most critical aspect of dryer safety.
Smouldering, a slow and hidden combustion process, is a major ignition source. It often occurs in high-moisture zones, leading to fires or explosions. Early detection of smouldering is essential to avoid catastrophic incidents.
Carbon monoxide (CO) and moisture monitoring systems, such as Hobré systems, are highly effective. They provide real-time alerts, allowing operators to act before ignition occurs. Thus, CO detection stands as the most reliable preventative safeguard for spray dryer operations.
FAQs
Why are spray dryers considered an explosion risk?
Spray dryers handle fine organic powders that can form explosive dust clouds when dispersed in air. If the dust concentration, oxygen and ignition source align within a confined space, an explosion can occur. The risk is highest when materials are fully dried and most easily ignitable.
What is the explosion pentagon in spray drying systems?
The explosion pentagon describes the five conditions required for a dust explosion: combustible dust, oxygen, ignition source, dispersion of dust in air and confinement. All five must be present simultaneously for an explosion to occur in a spray dryer.
What is the difference between explosion venting and explosion suppression?
Explosion venting releases pressure and flame safely to a protected area while explosion suppression actively detects and extinguishes an explosion at its early stage using a suppressant agent. Suppression systems prevent pressure build-up whereas venting systems allow controlled release.
Why is explosion venting sometimes limited in spray dryers?
Explosion venting can be difficult in spray dryers because many systems are installed indoors. Vent ducts may be impractical due to building constraints and heat loss considerations which can limit where explosion pressure can safely be directed.
What is smouldering in spray dryers?
Smouldering is a slow flameless combustion process that occurs without visible flames. It produces heat and gases such as carbon monoxide and can develop in moist or agglomerated powder deposits inside the dryer, potentially leading to fire or explosion.
Why is carbon monoxide monitoring important in spray dryers?
Carbon monoxide monitoring detects early signs of smouldering before ignition occurs. By identifying abnormal combustion conditions in real time, CO systems allow operators to take preventative action and reduce the risk of fire or explosion.
What are the most common ignition sources in spray dryers?
Common ignition sources include electrostatic discharge, overheating, hot work, mechanical failure and smouldering deposits. These sources can ignite fine dust clouds if process conditions are not properly controlled.
How do explosion suppression systems protect spray dryers?
Explosion suppression systems detect the earliest stages of a deflagration and rapidly release a suppressant agent such as sodium bicarbonate. This absorbs heat and
